A wrap on Newsmakers

Our key takeaways from our recent Newsmaker series

G’day Kate Watson here. Our Newsmakers series has come to a close and I wanted to say thank you to anyone who tuned in. 

If you’re someone who has been meaning to listen, the podcast series is here, or if video is more your thing, all the episodes are on YouTube here. 

The reason for doing Newsmakers was - like everything we do at The Squiz - to inform. More than that, though, I really wanted to bring you people behind the news who I admire because they share a thoughtfulness about the big issues, a curiosity about the world and, importantly, an ability to see different perspectives. 

I think we achieved that. 

And certainly, when we are receiving feedback like this, I feel buoyed that we got there:

“The chat was insightful, entertaining, informed and genuine. Importantly it was a conversation, but one loaded with goodness for me as a listener to take away.”

Newsmakers covered a lot of news topics - hospitality and culture, local news, sport, lifestyle, politics, business, women and science. 

From Nick Shelton, the founder of Broadsheet, to Claire Stuchbery, the head of the Local and Independent News Association, to Chris Uhlmann, one of our most esteemed political editors. And then there was Murray Shaw, Executive Producer of the Olympics, Kerri Elstub, Head of Nine’s websites and John McDuling, editor of new kid on the block Capital Brief. The series culminated in interviews with Mia Freedman, Founder of Mamamia, the unrivalled Leigh Sales and finished with the extraordinary Dr Karl. 

They all had different things to offer but as I reflect on all the conversations, there are some of the common themes. So to wrap up this series, I wanted to share those with you. Scroll down to find out, or you can listen to our wrap-up podcast episode here. 

Your friend in news

Kate Watson

Takeaway 1: Being a journalist is a vocation

All of our guests spoke about the work they do with commitment and passion. They were all driven by a higher purpose, and for most, that was truth. For example, Chris Uhlmann, who studied to be a priest before finding his way into journalism, told me this story:

Kate: When did it click that this was the thing that you should be doing?

Chris: You know, one of the priests in the seminary, a guy called Jimmy Esler who was a tremendous canon lawyer. And what had happened before and he became, he was in the, studied in the same year, I think as Gough Whitlam. So going back a very, very long way and he had been hopeless at everything, he said. But then he found the law and just couldn't do it badly. And it was one of those things when I got into journalism, I found that it just felt like a natural fit to me.

Or this from Mia Freedman:

Mia: I am an absolute monster for content. I cannot get enough content. When I was growing up, I loved magazines, but the magazines I loved, which were like Dolly, Cosmo, Cleo when I got a bit older, they only came out once a month, and that wasn't enough. So I would buy everything from Women's Weekly to just everything, Women's Day, New Idea. Like I'd buy everything because I just loved the medium and I loved content. I could never get enough of it.

Takeaway 2: They are naturally optimistic

I asked each guest what they were hopeful about. Nick Shelton’s response stood out to me as he spent much of the interview explaining how tough the pandemic had been for the hospitality and arts sector, and just when it started to come back to life, the cost of living crunch hit. His view:

Kate: What are you most hopeful about?

Nick: I'm hopeful across the board, so I'm hopeful that the, the consumer confidence cost of living inflation, all these, all these sort of metrics that are important soften and that we can go back to growth and we can go back to sort of putting our shoulders back and head up and saying, OK, we, we've got some confidence and we're going out, we're sort of, you know, building, building our economy and, and building our businesses and, and living living life in sort of a, a positive state rather than sort of a, a sort of defensive state, which is what we're seeing at the moment.

On a lighter note, Kerri Elstub of Nine reminded me that when it comes to news most of what we click on and read is not about the most terrible things, but rather ‘why not to tie a ribbon to a suitcase’. And Leigh Sales, who has extensive experience in writing on the most terrible of news, reminded us all:

Kate: We hear a lot from our audience that this is just so hard to watch the news. The news anxiety is really real for people. How do we make sure people are still engaging with news?

Leigh: When you're watching the news, the nature of the news is it is going to emphasise the least likely thing to happen to you. So for example, when I was at university, we were taught a hundred helicopters might fly safely today, but the one that crashes is the one that is going to make the news. So basically we emphasize the aberration, not the most likely thing to happen. It's why everyone got so scared of dying of COVID during COVID because we talked about COVID deaths front and centre all the time, where actually for everyone under the age of 50, your chance of dying of COVID is really unusual. Same with vaccines, your chance of dying of a vaccine side effect, it's possible, but it's not probable. So I think when you see things on the news that rattle you, Dreamworld rollercoaster accident, young people dying from COVID vaccines, anyone dying from COVID, terrorist attacks, gun massacres, whatever. It helps to remind yourself the reason I'm seeing this on the news is because it's unusual and it is the least likely thing to happen to me. It could happen to me, but it almost certainly won't.

This brings me neatly to my third point….

Takeaway 3: The effects of the pandemic are still being felt in the industry

So many of our guests referenced the pandemic. From Dr Karl, who spoke about how our understanding of the virus and our response to it changed, to much more pointed commentary from Chris Uhlmann on why we haven’t questioned the response more deeply:

Kate: You were the political editor at Channel Nine during the pandemic.But you finished up towards the end, you say that you were sort of dismayed about the fact that we allowed doctors to sort of run the country. You did sort of mention your profession though as well and the way the media handled it all, how, how did you feel about that? 

Chris: Well, for a large part, we the media, we were the police force for the government, you know, it was that all of these people who were complaining about vaccine mandates and look, you know I said before the whole thing began, if there's a vaccine and it's efficacious and safe and you don't take it, you're an idiot because I had two uncles who had polio. So, you know, and saw one who was crippled for life, right? The polio vaccine was a miracle. Vaccines are a miracle. So I was, but that said I can understand why someone might have an issue with that and decide that they don't want to do that. It's not for me to judge them. You know, it is, it when the government basically says it's going to take your job off you if you don't get vaccinated. Well, that's a pretty big call now.

And then it came up again with Leigh Sales, she considers it to be the currently the most overlooked news story:

Kate:  I asked you to have a think about what you thought the most overlooked news story is at the moment.

Leigh: I think our Australia's response to the COVID pandemic, because that was so life changing for so many people, the policy responses that we adopted. And pretty much by the time we got to the end of the pandemic, everyone was tired of hearing about it. And so I'm not persuaded that we've actually had a proper examination of what are the long -term costs of the policies that we adopted and why did we choose that path. And so I think that that's something that should be looked at because we don't know when there could be another pandemic coming down the track. And every time I see a news story talking about mental health issues, children's education issues, or I think back to people that I interviewed on the program during that period, like people whose parents were in aged care and how we handled aged care, I feel like we have not done enough to get to the bottom of that, the way media covered it. The way politicians handled it, the reliance on epidemiologists and chief health officers. I just think the whole response across the whole area needs a really, really close deep dive look. 

Takeaway 4: Squizers are diverse in their opinions, but there is plenty we agree on…

Each week in this series, I asked you a question about something I was thinking about. The questions were broad - “do you get enough local news?”, “how often do you seek out business news?”, “what do you think is the most overlooked news story?” and “do you think about Western values like democracy and freedom?”.

We got thousands of responses and hundreds of comments, and we’ve shared quite a few over on our Instagram. But it was your response to that last question that stuck with me:

You care a lot about Australia and the big conversations about our nation - as do I. Finally, across the series, we received plenty of feedback. The vast majority of it was positive, but a few people expressed concerns about a guest we had or disagreed with an opinion expressed. But to revisit what I said at the top, we wanted to make you think, which is why this graph about what you got from the series made me happy:

It reminded me about the values behind the Squiz - we know you’re smart and can make up your own mind. But you’re also curious - like me.

Can’t wait to bring you the next series.

All the Newsmakers episodes in one easy place…

If you missed an episode or want to catch up on one, we’ve got you. You can find all the podcast episodes in our News Club feed, watch them on our YouTube channel, or check out our newsletter archive by clicking the image below.

Keen to show us some love?

The easiest way to support us is by forwarding this newsletter or sharing the podcast episode with someone you think will enjoy it.

If you want to get fancy, use the unique link below, and we’ll know you sent them our way.

Copy and paste this link and share it around: